The One Thing Nonprofits Often Overlook in Their Marketing

April 9, 2025

Nonprofits are driven by purpose, passion, and impact—but too often, their marketing strategy doesn’t reflect that. Many organizations pour time and effort into fundraising, programs, and community outreach, yet struggle to gain the visibility and engagement they need.  So what’s missing?


The answer is simple:  Strategic storytelling in grassroots marketing.


In this post, we’ll break down why these two elements are crucial and how your nonprofit can use them effectively.

The Power of Storytelling in Nonprofit Marketing

People connect with people, not just causes. Nonprofits that struggle with engagement often focus too much on facts, figures, and mission statements—but the real magic happens when you tell compelling stories.


💡 Ask yourself:

  • Are we showcasing the faces behind our mission?
  • Do we tell before-and-after transformation stories?
  • Are we making people feel emotionally connected to our cause?

Example: Instead of saying, “We serve 500 families in need each month,” share a story of one family whose lives were changed because of your organization.


👉 Action Step: Identify 2-3 powerful stories from your nonprofit and create content (videos, blogs, social posts) that highlight real people and real impact.

Grassroots Marketing: Your Secret Superpower

Nonprofits often think they need huge ad budgets or massive campaigns to gain traction. The truth? Some of the most effective marketing comes from grassroots efforts—starting small, personal, and local.


🔹 Leverage word-of-mouth: Encourage supporters, volunteers, and community members to share your work.
🔹
Collaborate with local businesses: Partner with coffee shops, gyms, or boutiques that align with your mission.
🔹
Get personal with storytelling: Host live Q&As, share testimonials, and invite people into your work.


Grassroots marketing isn’t about spending more—it’s about making deeper connections.

Repetition is Your Best Friend

One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make is assuming people already know what they do. The reality? People need to hear a message multiple times before it sticks.


Nike doesn’t stop saying ‘Just Do It.’ Your nonprofit shouldn’t stop reinforcing its key messages, either.


👉 Action Step: Pick three core messages about your nonprofit and make sure they show up in every piece of content—emails, social media, donor materials, etc.

Final Thoughts

Marketing for nonprofits isn’t about spending big—it’s about thinking smart. When you prioritize storytelling, grassroots efforts, and consistency, you’ll create deeper engagement and long-term impact.


💬 What marketing strategy has worked best for your nonprofit? Drop a comment below—I’d love to hear your thoughts!

April 17, 2025
You ever meet someone online and think, “Omg I LOVE their vibe”… and then you realize you have no idea what they actually do? Or worse—you do know what they offer, but their whole online presence gives “meh” energy instead of “YES, I need this in my life” energy? Yeah. That disconnect? That’s a brand vibe problem, and… it’s more common than you think. Because here’s the truth no one tells you: Your vibe is doing the talking before your content even kicks in . People feel your brand before they read your captions. Your visuals, your voice, your presence—it’s all part of the story. If your brand feels off, unclear, or kind of vanilla, that’s the message your audience is picking up on. And if you’re like, “Wait. Is my brand giving off the wrong vibe??” Keep reading. I’ve got you. 💛
April 10, 2025
Have you ever had a conversation go sideways because of a misunderstanding? As an entrepreneur, leader, or business owner, effective communication isn’t just a skill—it’s the foundation of successful relationships, collaborations, and growth . If you want to navigate difficult conversations without stress or tension , try these three communication strategies that will change how you handle conflict.
April 10, 2025
Let’s talk about that moment when you’re staring at a blank Google Doc, sipping your iced coffee, whispering “what the actual heck am I supposed to post today?” 😩 I’ve been there. And not just once. I used to spiral into overthinking mode, creating 17 different drafts of captions that all felt kinda… meh. Too boring. Too vague. Too “what’s the point?” And let’s be real—when your content doesn’t have strategy behind it, you end up burnt out, inconsistent, and wondering why no one’s buying from you. But once I ditched the fluff and started creating content rooted in how people actually make decisions ? Everything changed. More engagement. More leads. More “OMG I feel like you’re in my head” DMs. And today, I’m giving you a peek behind the curtain—because this isn’t just my content strategy… it’s one you can steal and start using today.
By Summer Wheatley April 9, 2025
We need to talk. If your marketing is feeling like a full-time job with part-time results, you’re probably making a few of these all-too-common mistakes. And I get it—marketing is A LOT. But if you’re putting in the effort, let’s make sure it’s actually working for you, yeah? So, let’s break down the five marketing mistakes that might be scaring away your dream clients—and how to fix them ASAP.
April 9, 2025
A few years ago, I was sitting at my kitchen table with my laptop, a -empty cup of coffee, and a to-do list that felt longer than my toddler’s bedtime routine. I was an entrepreneur — a real one now, with actual paying clients and a brand I was building from scratch. But there was one problem: I was exhausted . I had started my business because I was passionate about what I offered — but somehow, I’d ended up drowning in everything except the work I loved. Writing Instagram captions at midnight. Googling “how to build a sales funnel” while making lunch. Stressing over why my website wasn’t converting (after spending way too much time and money on it). It felt like I had to be the CEO and the marketer and the creative director and the entire social media department — all at once. And the loneliest part? I had no one to bounce ideas off of. No one to say, “Here’s what works — do this instead.” No one to remind me that I wasn’t actually failing, I just needed a strategy.
By Savannah Adams April 9, 2025
You started this thing because you had a passion — maybe you’re a creative, a coach, a consultant, a product genius. And now you’re supposed to also be a marketing expert? It’s a lot. Suddenly, you’re spending hours trying to figure out Instagram’s algorithm, Googling “how to write a sales page,” and wondering why your website isn’t bringing in leads. That’s exactly where Heart & Strategy comes in. We’re not just another agency pushing packages you don’t need. We’re built by an entrepreneur — for entrepreneurs. Because we know what it’s like to be where you are right now.
April 9, 2025
In today’s digital age, social media has transformed the way non-profits connect with supporters, share their missions, and raise funds. With billions of users across platforms like Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and LinkedIn, non-profits have unprecedented opportunities to reach a wide audience, engage with potential donors, and create impactful fundraising campaigns. This blog will explore how non-profits can effectively leverage social media for fundraising, providing actionable strategies, insights, and tips for maximizing impact.
By Savannah Adams April 9, 2025
In the rapidly evolving landscape of healthcare, effective marketing is essential for organizations looking to connect with patients and promote their services. However, healthcare marketing is unlike any other industry, as it is governed by a complex web of regulations designed to protect patient privacy, ensure truthful advertising, and uphold ethical standards. Navigating these compliance requirements can be challenging for healthcare organizations. In this blog, we will explore the essential marketing regulations that healthcare organizations must adhere to, helping you understand how to market your services responsibly and effectively.
By Savannah Adams April 9, 2025
In today’s fast-paced digital landscape, marketing doesn’t always have to be an expensive endeavor. Whether you’re a startup, a small business, or simply trying to tighten your budget, there are several impactful marketing strategies that you can implement without spending a dime. The key is knowing where to focus your energy for maximum return. In this blog, we’ll explore five free marketing efforts you can start today to boost your brand awareness, engage your audience, and drive growth.
By Savannah Adams March 22, 2025
We love working with entrepreneurs and early-stage startups — the dreamers, the doers, the ones bringing bold ideas to life. Whether you’re launching your very first offer, pivoting into a new niche, or building a brand from scratch, we’re here to help you start strong. These projects are fast-moving, purpose-driven, and packed with potential — and we bring the strategy, design, and structure to help it all take off.
Show More